The Amazing Meeting 2014

Like it? Share it!

Sign up for news and updates!






Enter word seen below
Visually impaired? Click here to have an audio challenge played.  You will then need to enter the code that is spelled out.
Change image

CAPTCHA image
Please leave this field empty

Login Form



Skeptical Africa: Witchcraft and African Development PDF Print E-mail
Swift
Written by Leo Igwe, JREF Research Fellow   
An editorial in a Tanzanian newspaper, The Citizen, has rightly identified the belief in witchcraft as a barrier to development in the region. Witchcraft beliefs constitute serious obstacles to progress in the areas of justice, education, health, infrastructure, and more. Witch beliefs remain strong in Africa despite "rapid scientific and technological advancements." In fact, some scholars have argued that the growing trend of witchcraft accusation in Africa is a reaction to the exigencies of modernity. In Tanzania, as in other parts of Africa, witchcraft is a lingering custom that predates modernity. Witchcraft is a way many people explain and react to evil or misfortune, and to strange or extraordinary phenomenon.

The people in Tanzania "fallaciously attribute their existential predicaments to witchcraft. Problems such ill health, tragedies, drought, inclement weather, vermin outbreaks, loss of employment or poor harvests are wrongly believed to have been caused by supernatural powers."

Incidentally, those often suspected of witchcraft are persons who are made scapegoats of the ‘failings’ of the society. And they include women (particularly elderly women), children, and people with disabilities.

According to the editorial, people in Tanzania are “fed with fear, rumours and lies that instil and harbour suspicion, enmity, jealousy, despair and revenge” by pastors and witch doctors. They poison family and community relationships, causing members to turn against each other.

The editorial draws attention to the scale of the problem.

"Worse still is the fact that some preachers of certain denominations instil fear in their followers, making them believe that all their negative situations are a consequence of sin or the work of witches and evil spirits. Some houses of worship even discourage their flock from going to hospital when they fall sick, since exorcism and prayers and touch of their anointed hands will [allegedly] cure them.

"Suspected witches or sorcerers – often old people with red eyes, dry skin, wrinkled faces or those badly deformed – are systematically hunted down and killed in cold blood in various parts of the country.”

Misfortunes like these, affirms the editorial, have nothing to do with witchcraft.

“While we respect freedom of worship and religion, we firmly believe human failings, misfortunes, illnesses and accidental or natural deaths have nothing to do with witchcraft.

"Granted, you could suffer injury, poor health or even death thanks to your negligence or someone else’s evil schemes, but then, that would be scientifically verifiable. However, some of our people rush to conclude that you are a victim of some sorcerer’s machinations. Tanzanians must learn to solve problems rationally instead of looking for external and unverifiable causes. We also appeal to law enforcers to play their part and bring to book those who take the law into their own hands.”

Such appeals have, in the past, fallen on deaf ears due to fears and panic associated with witchcraft. There is a lack of political will - on the part of authorities -to enforce anti witchcraft laws in African countries because most law enforcers believe in witchcraft and fear spiritual repercussions.

Apart from fear, corruption is another factor hampering efforts to combat witchcraft-related abuse. For instance, in Calabar, in Southern Nigeria, efforts to bring to book those implicated in the murder of a 5 year old girl, Goodness Offiong, for witchcraft have yet to yield result. In August, Goodness was reportedly accused of witchcraft by the mother who took her to a prayer house in the city for an exorcism. She allegedly died - was tortured to death - in the course of being exorcized. A local child rights group, the Basic Rights Counsel, reported the case to the police. But the police are dragging their feet and have yet to act. They are asking the petitioners to "mobilize" (bribe) them before they can commence a thorough investigation. In Nigeria, individuals or groups who petition the police are often expected to bribe or "mobilize" the police before they can commence investigation into any case.

 

 

Leo Igwe is a research fellow for the James Randi Educational Foundation, and a regular contributor to randi.org.
Trackback(0)
Comments (3)Add Comment
Is there an up-side?
written by denver, November 11, 2012
I've noticed in other cultures, pseudo-scientfiic medical beliefs seemed to be tolerated, even encouraged, by the government when there is not sufficient reliable medical care available to the general public. In China for example acupuncture, if I recall, is endorsed by the Chinese government, I suspect because there is insufficient (or affordable) western medical care for all the people, and so this action by the government helps to keep the public from revolt.

The article you discussed seems to address and classify witchcraft as a negative part of people's lives. But I am curious if you think people see positive elements in it as well? For example, do people believe it can help them be free of problems or illnesses, even where there is no claim that a witch caused these things? Are there lacks of governmental services (law, medicine, etc) that allows witchcraft to seem to fill a void, in a way that the people, and even the government, figure witchcraft is better than nothing? If so, then it seems to me unless these issues themselves are addressed, tying to educate people on the down-side of superstitions will not be effective, since they still have an up-side to which to appeal.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
...
written by TofuFighter, November 13, 2012
We in South Africa held a successful Soccer World Cup in 2010, and our government, by way of the relevant sports authorities, actually paid a witchdoctor (or 'Sangoma') as they are referred to here) for his service of ensuring some success. (http://www.iol.co.za/sport/soc...-1.1309544).

I have often been surprised at highly intelligent people in my country, friends of mine, categorically claiming their belief in witchcraft. It really shouldn't, because many highly intelligent people also believe in god. Certainly I agree that development in Africa is hindered by adherence to some of the more primitive beliefs and traditions.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +1
...
written by Peebs, November 13, 2012
Surely all religion is ruled by fear.

If you kill, steal or covet your neighbour's wife you'll go to hell.

I don't kill or steal because I know it's wrong (coveting the neighbour's wife would obviously depend on her attractiveness and willingness!).

And they say I lack morality because I'm an atheist.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +1

Write comment
This content has been locked. You can no longer post any comment.
You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy