Like it? Share it!

Sign up for news and updates!






Enter word seen below
Visually impaired? Click here to have an audio challenge played.  You will then need to enter the code that is spelled out.
Change image

CAPTCHA image
Please leave this field empty

Login Form



JREF and PhACT Issue Challenge to "Therapeutic Touch" Practitioners PDF Print E-mail
Swift
Written by D.J. Grothe   

The James Randi Educational Foundation (JREF) in association with the Philadelphia Association for Critical Thinking (PhACT) formally issues its $1 Million Challenge to any Therapeutic Touch Practitioner (TTP) who can detect the Human Energy Field (HEF).The test will be held April 20, 2013 in Philadelphia at the Franklin Institute, one of America's leading hands-on science centers.

touch02Randi at the Therapeutic Touch challenge in 1997.

A success in this simple, direct, test could provide evidence for and would justify the continued existence and promotion of both Therapeutic Touch (TT) and the Energy Field Disturbance Nursing Diagnosis (EFD).

The existence of the Human Energy Field (HEF) is the entire basis of the “energy based therapy” known as Therapeutic Touch (TT). TT was created, and has been promoted as science, by the Nursing profession since the 1970's, which has claimed it is supported by Quantum Mechanics and research published by the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM).

 

 

Without actually touching the patient, Therapeutic Touch Practitioners (mostly nurses) claim

  1. that they can detect the HEF
  2. that they can detect irregularities in the HEF
  3. are able to correct them by manipulating the field

JREF and PhACT are only concerned for purposes of this Million Dollar Challenge with claim number one. Therapeutic Touch Practitioners claim that they can feel the Human Energy Field 4 to 8 inches from the surface of the human body. Therapeutic Touch appears in Nursing textbooks as a treatment and is taught in Nursing programs. therapeutic Touch courses are taught and are eligible for Continuing Education Credits which are necessary for advanced certifications and nursing licensure. The practice is supported by major nursing organizations, including the American Nurses Association. The American Nurses Association’s Code for Nurses is a nonnegotiable obligation to uphold and adhere to the code of ethics, the standard by which ethical conduct is guided and evaluated by the profession.

The “American Nurses Association Code for Nurses with Interpretive Statements" includes the following statement:

#10. The nurse participates in the profession's effort to protect the public from misinformation and misrepresentation and to maintain the integrity of nursing.

In regards to giving informed prior consent, the registered nurse performing Therapeutic Touch is responsible for assuring that patients, their families and/or legal guardians are educated and given adequate and accurate information about the treatment. As part of the TT diagnostic portion of the procedure, nurses claim to be able to feel the Human Energy Field (HEF). There is no evidence that HEF fields exist other than TT practitioners’ (TTP) claims that they can feel them. TTPs routinely use this claim to gain the confidence of the patient. If TTPs cannot feel the HEF, then they are misinforming the public, misrepresenting themselves and their abilities, and damaging the integrity of nursing. 

touch01The Therapeutic Touch challenge.

NANDA International, formerly the North American Nursing Diagnosis Association, is an organization formed in 1982 and it develops and defines Nursing Diagnoses for the entire profession. In their Mission Statement, NANDA states that they “are committed to improving the quality of nursing care and improvement of patient safety through evidence-based practice.”

In the NANDA guidelines, under the listing "Energy Field Disturbance," the section "Definition" shows that the diagnosis is totally dependent on Therapeutic Touch and the claim that TT practitioners can feel a Human Energy Field. The "Defining Characteristics" section mentions the perception of changes in patterns of the energy flow. Terms used include “warmth,” “coolness,” “spike,” “hole,” “bulge,” “tingling,” “flowing,” and “dense.”

This is not the first time that James Randi and PhACT have challenged the alternative medicine practice known as Therapeutic Touch. In 1997, the organizations jointly issued a challenge to over 40,000 Therapeutic Touch Practitioners for a prize of $742,000 if it could just be proven that the Human Energy Field could be detected. Only one Therapeutic Touch Practitioner was confident enough in her powers to step forward to be tested. She failed the challenge.

JREF and PhACT propose a simple, yes-or-no, scientific test to determine whether any person, Therapeutic Touch Practitioner or not, can detect the claimed Human Energy Field, thus providing evidence for and justifying the continued existence and promotion of the Energy Field Disturbance Nursing Diagnosis. JREF's $1 Million Prize will be awarded to anyone who applies for and wins JREF's Million Dollar Challenge.

Trackback(0)
Comments (4)Add Comment
How many studies?
written by Mike Syxx, March 15, 2013
D.J.,

It's kind of sad that a nine-year-old Emily Rosa could easily disprove TT. Why would TT believers think that studies conducted by National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine would be any more relative than actual medical and scientific study?!

report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +5
...
written by lytrigian, March 15, 2013
That's not sad, it's fantastic! Do you want to show how easy it is to approach a question scientifically? How it's really child's play to think critically? How little the scientific community resembles a secretive cabal or priesthood that hides their secrets away from the prying eyes of the public? Emily Rosa's experiment is perfect. Look, a 9 year old can do it, with no special training or initiation or anything. You don't even need a huge budget. All that's required is that you have a brain and you know how to use it.

This may be embarrassing for agencies like the NCCAM, but I wouldn't call it sad.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +13
Betcha nobody's home
written by skepticnj, March 15, 2013
What happens if you give a test and nobody shows up? We're gonna find out.

report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Protocol and Publicity?
written by CLamb, March 21, 2013
How is this being publicized? What is the protocol? If I were a TT practitioner I would be reluctant to accept the challenge unless I knew the protocol ahead of time so that I could see if it was fair.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +2

Write comment
This content has been locked. You can no longer post any comment.
You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy