Donate to the JREF

Login Form



Like it? Share it!

Reich For The Wrong Reasons PDF Print E-mail
Swift
Written by Penn Bullock   
Tuesday, 10 November 2009 17:01

NASA is prospecting for water-ice on the moon. On October 9, it shot a space probe into a crater at 9,000 miles per hour. The impact kicked up a mile-high plume of dust, which was photographed for clues. NASA hopes it gleaned enough data from this one-off Old Faithful to tell if there's water-ice in the moon's pock marks and poles -- as has long been suspected, and not only by NASA. "We are blown away by the data returned," said Tony Colaprete, the mission's top scientist. If NASA's moon bombing turns up water-ice, another acronymic organization beginning in N will stand belatedly vindicated. Kind of. The existence of lunar ice was, after all, the keystone of the NAZI cosmogony.

In 1894, an Austrian engineer named Hans Horbiger had a revelation while peering at the moon through a telescope. With no expertise in astrophysics whatsoever, he was certain that the luminosity and texture of its surface meant it was glazed with ice. A few nights later he dreamt of flying through space, where a gigantic swinging pendulum confirmed that Newton's laws taper off at three times Neptune's distance from the Sun. The epiphanies kept coming, relentlessly as flatulence. Later, observing the explosion of steam at molten metal's contact with water, Horbiger became convinced that the clash of heat and ice had similarly formed the universe and all its astral bodies.

In 1912, Horbiger teamed up with an amateur selenographer, Phillip Fauth (who has a moon crater named after him). Together they published an ugly, lengthy, moronic tome, Glazial-Kosmogonie. The revealed word of the World-Ice Theory ("Welteislehre," or WEL for short), it extolled ice as the most elemental substance in the cosmos.

After WWI, in the surrealist downward spiral of Weimar Germany, the WEL was constituted like a political party, with rallies, leaflets, posters, think tanks, and periodicals that galvanized legions of followers. Among them was British-born Houston Stewart Chamberlain, a pan-German occultist, Nazi founding father, and, as it happens, a devoted posthumous son-in-law of Richard Wagner. Chamberlain disdained the scientific method. "One of the most fatal errors of our time," he said, "is that which impels us to give too great weight to the so-called 'results' of science." Another demented mythologist, yet again a Brit, Hans Schindler Bellamy, regurgitated the WEL in a slew of books. His seminal Moons, Myths and Man is so chock full of fairy tales and (as it were) lunacy that summarizing it is like trying to recount a disjointed, nonsensical dream. Bellamy believed, like Horbiger, that the Earth has gone through a series of moons, at least seven. The capture of our present-day moon, Luna, some thousands of years ago, had warped the tides, flipped the magnetic poles, wrought worldwide flooding, and submerged Atlantis -- the center of Aryan civilization, according to spiritualist Madame Blavatsky, founder of Theosophy and Nazi forerunner. Bellamy corroborated the WEL's great-flood myth with other great-flood myths, especially Noah's Ark. To Bellamy it was obvious that Aryans had settled in the Himalayas and the Andes to escape the global deluge; and that, in the low pressure and gravity of the mountain chains, they had grown to become the literal race of "giants" spoken of in the Bible.

Hans Horbiger died in 1931, before Hitler's assumption of power, but WEL fans kept the movement alive by pushing all the right buttons with the ascendant Nazis. "Our Nordic ancestors grew strong in ice and snow," WEL wackos propagandized. "Belief in the Cosmic Ice is consequently the natural heritage of Nordic Man." And: "Just as it needed a child of Austrian culture -- Hitler! -- to put the Jewish politicians in their place, so it needed an Austrian to cleanse the world of Jewish science." It was all very convincing to the Nazi Party. They liked the WEL's Aryan historiography and the ice-theme, and they sought a volk science as eagerly as a Volkswagen. Under the Nazi regime, the WEL became the state cosmology.

When Adolf Hitler drew up plans for a massive planetarium in his hometown of Linz, he dedicated two floors to Ptolemy's and Copernicus's models of the universe and a top floor to Horbiger, whom Hitler called the "German Copernicus." Meantime, the occult-obsessed Heinrich Himmler and his think-tank, the Ahnenerbe, adopted and fine-tuned the WEL as a means of weather forecasting. (The Ahnenerbe is most famous for its crusade to find the grail.) Himmler dispatched his goon researchers to Tibet, not only to prove that Buddha was an Aryan, but also to trek into the Himalayas and test the WEL's utility in meteorology.

And here's where the history gets extremely weird. According to Unholy Alliance: A History of Nazi Involvement With The Occult, which boasts a foreword by Norman Mailer, Hitler sent his armies into Russia without the needed winter supplies "because the Horbigerians -- under the auspices of the Ahnenerbe's meteorological division -- had predicted a mild winter."

The WEL was wrong about that mild winter and just about everything else. The moon, contrary to Horbiger's postulation, is not spiraling inward toward Earth; it's actually inching away. The Milky Way is not comprised of ice-balls (though the Oort cloud is). And the moon is most certainly not coated in a layer of ice miles thick, though a 1999 NASA mission to the moon found evidence of up to 300 tons of the stuff buried in the poles.

In retrospect, though, Horbiger can seem like a crude visionary. He was uncannily on the mark about the universality of hydrogen, oxygen, and ice. NASA has even spotted signs of ice in the craters on Mercury. And when it comes to the moon, there's a good chance he'll get the last laugh.

In the '20s, Horbiger had an ornery exchange with Willy Ley, the German, anti-Nazi rocket scientist and sci-fi writer who -- with his pro-Nazi doppelganger, Werner von Braun -- launched America into space. Ley explained to Horbiger that the moon is boiling hot under direct sunlight and can't sustain ice at all. Horbiger, in a typical totalitarian flourish, responded: "... either you believe in me and learn, or you must be treated as an enemy." In retrospect, Ley should've believed him. Today we know that many of the moon's craters are the coldest places in the Solar System, as they're shielded eternally from the sun. NASA blitzkrieged one of those craters -- indeed, did so using rocket technology partially ripped off from the Nazis.

The Nazi party's narrow scientific advancements may have set the launch pad for man's leap into space. But it doesn't follow, as the Daily Mail opined last week, that the Nazis created "hell on earth" by believing "with babyish credulity, in science as the only truth." Quite the opposite. They believed, with New Age zeal, in the WEL and the worst of the woo.

Trackback(0)
Comments (23)Add Comment
It came to me in a dream...
written by the bible is useless, November 09, 2009
I am quite tired of that old "the Nazi's worshiped science as their god" and "Hitler learned everything from Darwin" nonsense. The Nazi ideology came entirely from woo and occultism, with a heavy dose of artificial selection. But modern woo is fueled by the same sort of thinking as that which led to a theory of ice on the moon based on seeing an ice-like reflection in the moon. That's not science. Woo-thinking would also jump to the conclusion that finding ice on the moon now "confirms" that he was on to something, in the same way that if I dream of a fire and wake up to find out a plane crashed in California, it confirms that I am "sensitive" and foresaw the event in my dreams (Where's my $1 million???).

Nazi's also believed that Aryan couples conceiving in certain graveyards would allow their unborn to be infused with perfect genes AND the spirits of dead Teutonic warriors. Does that sound like a culture that lives by science and reason?
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +23
Visionary?
written by GusGus, November 09, 2009
Horbiger was no visionary. According to your post, he thought the moon was COVERED in ice. It's not covered in ice. NASA is hoping that ice is below the surface in certain perpetually-cold craters.

By the way, NASA is not looking for ice-water, it's looking for water-ice (as opposed to methane-ice, or carbon_dioxide-ice, etc.). Ice water is the stuff we drink (very cold LIQUID water), which cannot exist on the moon.

This post is very confusing. What point is Bullock trying to make?
.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +4
Corrected
written by bkthorp, November 09, 2009
GusGus:

Thank you for pointing out the error. "Ice-water" has now been changed to "water-ice."

As to your other points, I think a careful reading of the story will show that Bullock has acknowledged how wacky Horbiger was, and clearly shows that what he got right, he got right through chance. The purpose of the story, if I am reading the last paragraph correctly, is to show that the Nazi worldview was not only pure woo, but woo of an especially nutty variety -- contrary to the opinions currently making their way through US News and World Report and The Daily Mail.

- BKT
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +11
...
written by Willy K, November 09, 2009
Horbiger, in a typical totalitarian flourish, responded: "... either you believe in me and learn, or you must be treated as an enemy."
He is 100% accurate in that tatement.

That statement is the basic premise for ALL religions! smilies/tongue.gif
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +9
Oops...
written by Willy K, November 09, 2009
Statement! Not Tatement! smilies/shocked.gif
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +1
...
written by Sean Sturgeon, November 09, 2009
This post is very confusing. What point is Bullock trying to make?


The article also does a nice job of reminding us all how the Nazi worldview was not one balanced on the shoulders of science, but was a rather unique mix of abused technology and occultist idiocy.

Given how frequently the supposed scientific nature of Hitler's Reich gets thrown in the face of 'our side' by the creationists, Bullock is making an very important and timely point.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +12
...And?
written by Wiz, November 09, 2009
Most of the founding fathers of modern science were wacko woo woos. Newton and his contemporaries were ALCHEMISTS and stumbled upon chemistry and physics while trying to turn lead into gold.

The point is you have to be a little bit crazy to discover anything novel, right? If you aren't, you certainly won't find anything new if you think in predictable, established ways.

We really haven't had a scientific breakthrough of paradigm-shifting proportions since Einstein's era. Just little things here and there, tweaks and process improvements.. but little in the way of life-changing.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: -13
...
written by outsorcerer, November 09, 2009
How soon before the woo-wooers start selling imported bottled "moon water" with its special "moon properties" that "cure" all manner of ills? smilies/grin.gif
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +9
Newton was no wacko ...
written by Mark P, November 09, 2009
Newton believed in the scientific method. It was just that the state of Chemistry at the time was not advanced enough to distinguish what was possible and what was not. Prior to the identification of the concept of elements, transmutation was a reasonable theory.

To be wacko is to believe in transmutation after the periodic table is laid out.

The idea the scientific geniuses are part crazy is, well, part crazy. (If it has any truth, then it is with the pure mathematicians, who need a very particular kind of intensity to be successful. And even then it will only be a slight tendency.)
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +13
...
written by MadScientist, November 09, 2009
A victim of Godwin's Principle before anyone even had a chance to post a comment.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +3
>:'3
written by Quakeulf, November 09, 2009
"NASA, what does the speedometer say about the space probe's speed?"

NASA: "It's over 9000!!!"
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +4
...
written by advancedGIR, November 09, 2009
"capture of our present-day moon, Luna, some thousands of years ago, had warped the tides, flipped the magnetic poles, wrought worldwide flooding"
Don't know about the magnetic poles, but I clearly remember having read that our large moon had a significant stabilizing effect on earth rotation and climate.

"in the low pressure and gravity of the mountain chains, they had grown to become the literal race of "giants""
Aren't mountain people rather short? I guess the limited oxygen density has more effect than a fraction of percent reduction of gravity, plus very probably a bad diet, mountains are not known for their diverse food supply.

"Belief in the Cosmic Ice is consequently the natural heritage of Nordic Man."
Well, THAT makes sense, but I don't think the author of that sentence understood it is an argument against his theories.

"The moon, contrary to Horbiger's postulation, is not spiraling inward toward Earth"
I'm not sure it is that simple, didn't Hitler believe in the hollow earth theory (we live on the inner side of the earth and all the cosmos is in the central empty space), wouldn't that make the moon spiraling OUTWARD towards earth? my brain hurts...
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +2
Transmutation
written by advancedGIR, November 10, 2009
To Mark P, transmutation is possible (with a particule accelerator and a lot of electricity), it is simply totally moronic to use it to get something you can simply mine. Transmutation is actually the only way to obtain trans-uranium atoms.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +2
russian winter
written by cthulhu_4_president, November 10, 2009
Very neat and informative article, however something in this tidbit made my skeptic sense tingle:

.... Hitler sent his armies into Russia without the needed winter supplies "because the Horbigerians -- under the auspices of the Ahnenerbe's meteorological division -- had predicted a mild winter."


My father is a professor of World War II military history and strategy, and it was his input that the Germans lacked the supplies to survive the Russian winter partly because they were very arrogant from the success and speed of their conquests so far. Basically, they thought the job would be done by winter. Also, German intelligence under-counted the Russian army by several hundred percent. This, coupled with the fact that the German General staff were very unlikly to seriously listen to the Ahnenerbe or Horbiger regarding campiagn strategy, makes it very difficult to meaningfully link the failure of the Russain campaign with Nazi belief in a defunct cosmological system.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +13
...
written by Caller X, November 10, 2009
Prior to the identification of the concept of elements, transmutation was a reasonable theory.

To be wacko is to believe in transmutation after the periodic table is laid out.


and

written by advancedGIR, November 10, 2009
To Mark P, transmutation is possible (with a particule accelerator and a lot of electricity), it is simply totally moronic to use it to get something you can simply mine. Transmutation is actually the only way to obtain trans-uranium atoms.


You guys do know that transmutation is a natural process that is occurring all the time, right? You don't need a particule [sic] accelerator at all. AdvancedGIR, meet my little buddies Plutonium and Neptunium. And somewhere far down the line, Lead.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +3
'Nazi' is not an acronym.
written by warreno, November 10, 2009
It's a contraction of Nationalsozialistische Deutsche Arbeiterpartei. (You can see why they went with "Nazi" instead.)
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +1
...
written by tctheunbeliever, November 10, 2009
Totally irrelevant, but I really did lol when I read that "Mein Kampf" was popularly known as "Mein Krampf" ("My Diarrhea").
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
...
written by pxatkins, November 10, 2009
Too much sarcasm in that article.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +1
...
written by Phd.Hyper D, November 10, 2009
Oh my, Knowing more of the science than anyone here ever does makes an old Papa like me laugh and laugh at NASA and the manifestations of commentary of subjects that mostly have no connection to the article,whats up guys? The moons are placed in the hyperdimensional cymatic rings at the correct distance to provide a pull to slow the spin speed of a sphere and this place is not an accident,we live in a built ,engineered system,Guaranteed.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: -16
transmutation
written by sibtrag, November 11, 2009
Transmutation is responsible for all of our elements heavier than hydrogen. Much of it occurred in stars now long gone.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Transmutation Trash
written by Phd.Hyper D, November 11, 2009
Elements are not transmuted,but the woo-woo folks have alot of people believing it.Guys in my contingent can produce gold in 6 months by densifying and alloying.The densified metal salt lead only takes 3 days.Get a grip on yourselves woo woo NASA-ites. This old papa has the top science position on the planet,but you never see me,I just putz from time to time to give possibilities of conscious thought,but not many are capable of that. There is something very big afoot and you will see the resultant of many processes.One of which is Star Wars,Bye Now.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: -12
Transmutation
written by advancedGIR, November 11, 2009
Yes, plutonium and a few other non-natural isotopes obtained in industrial quantities with a breader generator (a nuclear power plant tuned towards generation of heavy isotopes rather than optimal electricity production), but this can only apply to isotopes that have a half-life long enough to survive the delay of the industrial process (for example, the most recently observed element, that will probably be named copernicium, has a half-life of only 11 minutes and had to be created on the spot, from webelements.com: "the zinc atom was accelerated to high energies by the heavy ion accelerator UNILAC at GSI and directed onto a lead target", note the use of singular, on the other hand, plutonium has a half-life over 20000 years and therefore can be stored).

My point was that you could probably use that king of technique to create gold, but it would be so slow and expensive that it can be an option only for things you can't find naturaly.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
@Outsourcer
written by RobbieD, November 12, 2009
"How soon before the woo-wooers start selling imported bottled "moon water" with its special "moon properties" that "cure" all manner of ills?"

Did we not have a link in Swift a little while ago to a paper by an astrologer and homoeopath who was using a telescope to focus the light from stars and planets onto bottles of water to give them homoeopathic healing properties? I think the woo woo water is already with us.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0

Write comment
You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy
Last Updated on Tuesday, 10 November 2009 12:31